How property managers can get more Google reviews

A fair, practical way for property management agencies to get more Google reviews from landlords and tenants, and what the rules say about asking.

When a landlord looks for a new property manager, Google reviews are one of the first things they check. Agencies with plenty of recent, genuine reviews look trustworthy. Agencies with a few old reviews, or only complaints, struggle to win the meeting.

Property management has a particular challenge: unhappy tenants are often the most motivated to post, while happy landlords rarely think to. This article covers how to change that fairly.

Who to ask

  • Landlords. The people choosing you, and the most influential reviews for new business.
  • Tenants. Good tenant experiences show a well-run agency.
  • Sellers and buyers. If your agency also does sales.

When to ask

TimingGood moments to ask for a review
  • New lease signed The landlord has a tenant and a property earning rent.
  • A repair handled well The problem was fixed quickly and clearly.
  • End of a good tenancy The tenant is leaving on good terms with their bond returned.
  • Anniversary A landlord’s first year with your agency.

Ask everyone, fairly

It’s tempting to only ask landlords and tenants you know are happy. Google’s policies don’t allow businesses to ask only happy customers, a practice called review gating, or to offer incentives for reviews. The ACCC also warns against misleading reviews. The fair approach is also the simplest: ask at the same moments, every time, and let people say what they think.

Make it easy

Send a short message with a direct link to your Google review page, use the person’s name and mention the moment. For example: “Thanks for trusting us with 12 Smith Street, Alex. If you’re happy with how the leasing went, a quick Google review would really help us.”

Respond to every review

Thank people for positive reviews. For negative ones, reply calmly, without sharing personal details, acknowledge the concern and offer to talk offline. Future landlords read your replies as closely as the reviews.

The same principles apply in other industries. See how tradies can get more Google reviews.

How Shift AI asks for reviews

Shift AI sends a review request when a lease, sale or job is won and done, as part of Query to Review. It asks everyone at the same moment, rather than picking and choosing, and it doesn’t monitor or reply to reviews, so you stay in control of your Google profile.

  • Every enquiry answered. By phone, chat, SMS and email, day and night.
  • Every enquiry followed up. Buyer, seller, tenant and owner enquiries chased until there’s a decision.
  • Every request tracked. Requests go to the right person and stay visible until they’re done.
  • Our AI always says it’s AI. Your customers always know who they’re talking to.

Setup is free, you pay once your agent is live and working, and we go live in two weeks. See how Shift works for property managers, or book a free AI strategy sprint.

Frequently asked questions

Should I ask tenants for reviews?

Yes, at good moments such as a repair handled well or a smooth end of tenancy. Ask fairly, not selectively.

Can I offer a discount on fees for a review?

No. Google doesn’t allow incentives for reviews.

How do I respond to a negative tenant review?

Calmly, without personal details. Acknowledge the concern and offer to discuss it offline.

When is the best time to ask a landlord?

Soon after a positive milestone, such as a new lease being signed.

Free AI strategy sprint

Let's get your customers handled.

In 30 minutes, we'll look at how your customers reach you today, show you where they slip through, and map the right mix for your business. Then we look after the rest.

Free setupLive in two weeksPay once it's live and working